I agree with ps_minor about the build quality. You could use the
controller as a means of self defense. I take mine with me whenever
I travel at night.

As for comparing the A198 to a Moog ribbon controller, in what way do
you mean, and which controller The 956, or the controller meant for
the Minimoog

As for size, the Moog controller is much bulkier. The controls on
the Moog are slightly more limited than the Doepfer (i.e. the A198
has two gate outs, as well as pressure). Also, I find the Doepfer to
be slightly smoother in response, but this really shouldn't be that
shocking because the Moog controller was manufactured in the 1970s (I
think it was 74 actually), and components have progressed quite a bit
since then.

At the end of the day, it would be best to A-B them and form your own
opinion. If you're a collector, the Moog 956 will be more to your
liking. If you're looking for a controller that will see regular
use, my call is the A198, if for no other reason you can get it fixed
if a problem arrises... and the LEDs. Yes, the LEDs.

Regards,
Kevin

--- In Doepfer_a100@yahoogroups.com , "ps_minor" <pscottm@h...> wrote:
> hello, i just rec'd my 198 a couple days ago and i love it. the
build quality is
> impressive. and while i've never used a mogg ribbon, i can say the
a198
> response to position is very good. the response to pressure
requires a bit
> more force than i'd like, but it's useful and i'm sure i can get
used to it. i also
> have the a113 and a104 and am impressed w the authenticity of the
sound
> when controlled by an a198. i'm no oscar sala but could be soon!
>
> --- In Doepfer_a100@yahoogroups.com , "analogue100"
<analogue100@y...>
> wrote:
> > Hello all,
> > I'm planning on buying an A-198. Can you share your experiences
with
> > me please Can it be compared to an old Moog ribbon controller